
$90 Placebo Effect: How Price Tags Rewrite Sensory Reality
Social Sciences
By
Hyeseung (Estelle) Lee
Introduction
We liked to believe our senses are objective. When we sip a drink, listen to music, or taste a meal, we assume our brain is processing raw data. However, a growing number of neuro research has shown that our experience does not justify our judgments – rather it is our expectations that rewrite the physical reality. The clearest example of this effect is known to psychologists as White Snob Paradox.
The Anatomy of Illusion
"Studies have shown that people enjoy identical products such as wine or chocolate more if they have a higher price tag," wrote Hilke Plassmann (INSEAD) and Bernd Weber (University of Bonn). (1)
This theory is supported in a neuroimaging study led by a California Institute of Technology (Caltech) professor and colleagues. Ranger et al. found that changes in the stated price of a sampled wine influenced not only how good volunteers thought it tasted, but the activity of a brain region that is involved in our experience of pleasure. (2)
In the experiment, participants were placed inside fMRI scanner to track brain activity real time while given a sip of identical wines. The only variable that changed was the stated retail price of the bottle, ranging from $5 to $90.
The results were predictable: the subjects constantly rated $90 wine as more flavorful, complex and enjoyable than $5 wines.
If this were a simple case of social compliance – people lying to appear more sophisticated – the fRMI would have reported normal sensory processing. However, the brain scans revealed a brain region called medial orbitofrontal cortex, or mOFC, showed higher activity when subjects drank wines they believed were expensive. This neurological region is responsible for encoding experienced pleasantness experiences. In other words, participants were not pretending to enjoy certain wines more; the artificial construct of retail prices had rewrote the biological mechanics of taste.
The Phenomenon Explained
This phenomenon relies on a psychological process called top-down processing. The human brain is a predictive engine using shortcuts called heuristics to guess what an experience should taste like before it happens. (3) Consequently, instead of analyzing the flavors from the tongue up, we assume high cost equals high quality.
Conclusion
"Understanding the underlying mechanisms of this placebo effect provides marketers with powerful tools. Marketing actions can change the very biological processes underlying a purchasing decision, making the effect very powerful indeed," the researchers conclude. (4) Hence, awareness of this psychological impact highlights a fundamental truth about human perception: our sensory experience is active creation shaped by what we expect to feel.
Citations and Further Reading
Share:

About the Author
Hyeseung (Estelle) Lee
Hyeseung (Estelle) Lee


